Although it has been unseasonably warm this past week in the big smoke, it’s been crazy rainy and windy. It’s a perfect time to stay in and make some healthy comforting food that is great for lunch the next day. I posted this recipe in 2009 because it is an incredibly tasty and easy dish for a week night, but I find myself craving to repost as I really hated the old photo! This is still JTs signature dish so I won’t alter his recipe other than how it has morphed over the years, and it has morphed a touch over the years. But I will say, please make this, it is really, really, really good!
And don’t forget to enter the giveaway! I’m really excited about the give away and what creative things you will make with it and blog about. I did forget to detail the time the draw closes: 12pm Eastern Standard Time, that will give me some time to get the correct entries together and have JT do the draw! As well, the Just a Pinch salts were purchased entirely by ME! It is not linked to any other promo! Time is a tickin’ people, better enter soon!
And did I mention that a couple of the answers are found in more than one post? Oops! Good luck!
JTs Chicken Cacciatore
Adapted from Fannie Farmer, December 1984 (originally published in 1896!).
Serves 4 (2 dinners and 2 lunches in our case)
Ingredients:
- 400g chicken breasts, skinless, boneless
- 2 tbsp olive oil
- 28g dried mushrooms rehydrated in about 1 cup warm water, set liquid aside (make sure you strain through coffee filter to ensure no sand gets into it)
- 1 large onion, chopped
- 1/2 cup dry white wine (or low sodium chicken stock)
- 1 clove garlic, minced
- 1/2 red pepper, sliced (we used green this time because that is what we had)
- 1 tbsp tomato paste (put remaining tomato paste into an extra ice cube tray and freeze, remove from tray into a resealable container and voila, tomato paste as required!)
- 2 cups canned Roma tomatoes, peeled and chopped
- 1/2 tsp allspice
- 1 bay leaves
- 1/2 tsp thyme
- Chili peppers to taste
- Salt to taste
- Grated Parmesan, if you wish
Directions:
- Preheat oven to 350°F (or you could just cook the entire dish stove top with the lid on)
- Heat the oil in a large dutch oven and cook the chicken until lightly browned on all sides.
- Add the onion and sauté a minute or two and then add the wine and allow to boil up.
- Lower the temperature and add the garlic, tomato paste, tomatoes, pepper and the mushrooms.
- Add the seasonings, bay leaves and the mushroom liquid.
- Cover and bake in the hot oven for about 1 hour, or until chicken is cooked through. If you like a dryer cacciatore, leave the cover off so that some of the liquid evaporates; I prefer mine a bit wet so that it makes a tasty ‘dressing’ for the greens.
- Remove bay leaves, taste and season if required.
- Serve on a bed of mixed baby spinach and baby arugula leaves. You can also serve with grated Parmesan and a dollop of yogurt or sour cream, but we’re reducing our intake this week, so we omitted it.
Tips: You can also add black olives (chop in half) and crumble some sheeps milk feta on top instead of the Parmesan for a slightly Greek version of the dish.
I had to update this post with a photo I recently took with my iPhone at work. I just loved how rich the sauce looks and how luminous this photos is.



I love this chicken dish. And yours looks lovely Eva. So bright and colourful and I love how you have plated the dish. Good luck with the cold snap in the weather!
Thanks Charlie Louie, we got a slight dusting of snow yesterday afternoon, which makes the cold weather somehow worth it!
Thanks for sharing JT’s recipe, it looks fantastic! As you say it is healthy but hearty and packed with flavour
We generally put it on a leafy greens like spinach, Lorraine; the heat just ever so slightly wilts the spinach and it is rather delicious. But you can put it in pasta or mashed potatoes if you would prefer.
Great recipe, Eva. Chicken Cacciatore is a personal favorite and I prepare it frequently. In fact, I have the large frying pan Mom used when making it. I can’t help but feel a little nostalgic whenever I use it. Thanks for sharing.
That’s just wonderful, John. Please do prepare it soon, I’d love to see an authentic recipe.
I posted Mom’s recipe last April, Eva. Here’s the link:
http://fromthebartolinikitchens.com/2011/01/06/moms-chicken-thats-not-really-cacciatore/
I hope you do not mind my posting a link in your comments section. If it’s a problem, please delete it. It certainly won’t bother me if you do.
This looks like the best recipe for Chicken Cacciatore that I’ve seen, Eva! I’m bookmarking it, and I love the idea of the olives and feta version, even more. Truly yum!
It has become one of our go to recipes, Betsy. What I didn’t mention is that if you can cook the tomato sauce all day in a slow cooker, it will become the richest and most delicious tomato sauce you’ve ever had! Just cook up the chicken last minute so it remains in tact and not stringy!
Lovely recipe, great presentation as usual. If I made all the inspiring recipes on the blogs I follow, I’d have to open a restaurant to eat up all the food.
Right now I’m looking at the products of my own baking (onion/ dill weed and dill seed bread) and still planning a cream puffs which I’ve made before, a genoise cake or jelly roll and the ‘macarons from heck’. And then there is the Romanian version of Rakott Krumpli for this weekend.
So true, Maria. Too many recipes, so little time.
Looks just lovely and i can’t wait to win! I mean good luck to all.
Hehehe! You crack me up, Bob. I mean Greg
Love everything in this recipe and I’ll take both the parm and olives on top…i’m a glutton after all.
It is a flavourite in our home, for sure! And it’s a great lunch for me the following day, Jed. It tastes even better because I like a few hot chili flakes sprinkled on top.
What a beautiful presentation! I have been thinking lately about making chicken cacciatore – I’ll try this recipe.
Thank you kindly Lynda; layering it over greens helps us mitigate the calories and it’s so tasty (see my reply below). Do let me know how it works out.
I love the recipe Eva.I am always on the look out for new chicken recipe and this one checks all the boxes. Can’t wait to try it
This looks delicious! I’m glad you reposted it….and your picture is just lovely!
Thank you Ann, hope you had a chance to entre my first give away!
Chicken cacciatore sounds fantastic! I haven’t had that in long time. It sounds really good – especially in this dreary weather.
Hi Kristy, your family might like it on rigatoni or penne noodles; we serve it over spinach and arugula greens to mitigate the calories!
Hi Eva,
Call me a dummy-head, but I was wondering – how does one pronounce “cacciatore”? I was thinking maybe something like cha-chia-toray but not entirely sure
You know, I think I’ve had this before, but I had no idea this is what it was called! Ate it at a restaurant or something I think. I remember it was really good there, so it’s very fortuitous that you’ve posted a recipe now yourself. Thanks so much for sharing this
Hope you’re having a wonderful weekend!
Hi Charles! It’s pronounced how you’ve guessed but I think the ‘i’ is silent, like catch-a-torry. If you like a rich tomato sauce, this dish is for you! You can serve it on noodles, but we just drape it over greens.
Charles, check this website for pronouncing words.
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/cacciatore
By the way, I’m always amused by the similarities in recipes from different cultures, for example, the Italian cacciatore and the French chasseur. Both refer to a hunter or huntsman so the ingredients are similar in the 2 dishes.
I love your take on Chicken Cacciatore. it’s such an amazing dish and you just made it even better. Wonderful recipe
Thanks Kay, and welcome to my blog. It really is one of our go to weeknight dishes, and it’s absolutely to die for the next day for lunch. Hope you give it a go.
Love the presentation and photographs Eva. The chicken looks so delicious, what a perfect meal on a cold winter night.
Thank you Asmita, it is a delicious meal and made a fantastic lunch too.